Designing Assessments (2023)

Determining how and when students have reached course learning outcomes.

The importance of assessment

Assessments in education measure student achievement. These may take the form traditional assessments such as exams, or quizzes, but may also be part of learning activities such as group projects or presentations.

While assessments may take many forms, they also are used for a variety of purposes. They may

Guide instruction
Determine if reteaching, remediating or enriching is needed
Identify strengths and weaknesses
Determine gaps in content knowledge or understanding
Confirm students’ understanding of content
Promote self-regulating strategies
Determine if learning outcomes have been achieved
Collect data to record and analyze
Evaluate course and teaching effectiveness

While all aspects of course design are important, your choice of assessment Influences what your students will primarily focus on.

For example, if you assign students to watch videos but do not assess understanding or knowledge of the videos, students may be more likely to skip the task. If your exams only focus on memorizing content and not thinking critically, you will find that students are only memorizing material instead of spending time contemplating the meaning of the subject matter, regardless of whether you attempt to motivate them to think about the subject.

Overall, your choice of assessment will tell students what you value in your course. Assessment focuses students on what they need to achieve to succeed in the class, and if you want students to achieve the learning outcomes you have created, then your assessments need to align with them.

The assessment cycle

Assessment does not occur only at the end of units or courses. To adjust teaching and learning, assessment should occur regularly throughout the course. The following diagram is an example of how assessment might occur at several levels.

The assessment cycle

This cycle might occur:

During a single lesson when students tell an instructor that they are having difficulty with a topic.
At the unit level where a quiz or exam might inform whether additional material needs to be included in the next unit.
At the course level where a final exam might indicate which units will need more instructional time the next time the course is taught.

In many of the above instances learning outcomes may not change, but assessment results will instead directly influence further instruction. For example, during a lecture a quick formative assessment such as a poll may make it clear that instruction was unclear, and further examples are needed.

Assessment considerations

There are several types of assessment to consider in your course which fit within the assessment cycle. The two main assessments used during a course are formative and summative assessment. It is easier to understand each by comparing them.

	Formative	Summative
	Assessment for Learning	Assessment of Learning
Purpose	Improve learning	Measure attainment
When	While learning is in progress	End of learning
Focused on	Learning process and learning progress	Products of learning
Who	Collaborative	Instructor-directed
Use	Provide feedback and adjust lesson	Final evaluation

(Video) Designing quality assessment

An often-used quote that helps illustrate the difference between these purposes is:

“When the cook tastes the soup, that’s formative. When the guests taste the soup, that’s summative.”Robert E. Stake

Examples

Formative	Both	Summative
Homework Summaries Minute papers Diagrams Concept maps Graphic organizers Observation Worksheets Discussions Video responses Exit slips Reflections Peer assessments	Rubrics Checklists Journal entries Performance tasks Group assignments Comprehension questions Oral responses	Test Quiz Presentation Research paper Practicum or field work Portfolio Project

It is important to note, however, that assessments may often serve both purposes. For example, a low-stakes quiz may be used to inform students of their current progress, and an instructor may alter instruction to spend more time on a topic if student scores warrant it. Additionally, activities like research papers or presentations graded on a rubric contain both the learning activity as well as the assessment. If students complete sections or drafts of the paper and receive grades or feedback along the way, this activity also serves as a formative assessment for learning while serving as a summative assessment upon completion.

Best practices

Considerations

For assessments to accurately measure outcomes and to provide optimal feedback to students, the following should influence assessment choice and design:

Learning outcomes

Cognitive complexity
Options for expression
Course and Class

Assessment and grading

Weight of assessment
Time for grading and feedback
Delivery modes

Course level

Prerequisites and post learning
Class size
Time and length of course

Students

Practice opportunities
Accessibility and accommodations

Provide ongoing and varied methods

Because learning outcomes are unique, the types of knowledge and skills that demonstrate achievement of these outcomes will differ. Therefore, assessments will need to vary to capture this achievement. Consider using:

Ongoing assessments: Regular assessment helps determine where students are on the learning continuum. These allow for
- Evaluation of participation and engagement
- Opportunities for feedback
- Demonstrable learner progress
- Opportunities to test and apply their knowledge
Different types of evidence: The following resource summarizes the different types of evidence to determine progress and how this evidence can be collected.

Handout – Types of Evidence

Question types

There are several types of questions that you can use to assess student achievement. The following links explain question types and how to design high-quality multiple-choice questions.

Types of Questions

Overview of the different types of questions you can use for assessments.

(Video) How to design assessments (Comprehensive Content & Assessment Help)

Question Types (Blackboard)

Overview of all the question types available in Blackboard to design an assessment.

Writing Good Multiple Choice Test Questions (Vanderbilt)

Overview of how to construct high-quality multiple-choice test questions.

Alignment

At the beginning of choosing assessments for your course, you should start by reviewing the learning outcomes and then matching assessments to them. Assessments should align to the cognitive complexity (see Bloom’s Taxonomy) or type of learning (see Fink’s Taxonomy) of course learning outcomes.

For example, if your course outcomes expect students to be able to memorize or understand course content, exams with multiple choice questions may accurately assess these outcomes. If your outcome expects students to be able to create an original product, then a multiple choice question would not measure an innovative creation.

Instead, a project, graded with a rubric, may best assess this.

Blooms pyramid showing multiple choice questions as appropriate for the Understanding and Remembering stages, while not appropriate for the Creating stage.

Blooms pyramid showing a project as appropriate for the Creating and Evaluating stages.

If an assessment does not map onto an outcome, you should ask whether you are missing a course learning outcome you care about and, if not, whether your assessment is necessary. Further, you may need to adapt the assessment itself or even your choice in assessment to align with the learning outcome.

The accompanying chart is helpful in choosing and reviewing your assessments as you create them. You may find as you go that a course outcome might change as you determine how you will be able to assess it or if the scope of the learning outcome is too large for the time needed for the assessment.

If you find most outcomes are assessed using quizzes and exams, consider alternative methods of assessment.

Bloom’s Taxonomy - Levels of Knowledge, Associated Assessments & Verbs (Quinnipiac University)

(Video) Designing Assessments